Sometime ago I mentioned the Power 4 investment strategy suggested on one of the Dorsey Wright Associates (DWA) podcasts. DWA provides the portfolios for 9 PowerShare momentum strategy ETFs. Each ETF – PYZ Basic Materials, PEZ Consumer Cyclicals, PSL Consumer Staples, PXI Energy, PFI Financial, PTH Healthcare, PRN Industrials, PTF Technology, PUI Utilities – are managed in the same manner. The funds are updated each quarter with a minumum of 30 stocks within all within the sector selecting the stocks with the best momentum. A complete list of Invesco PowerShare ETFs and their current holdings holdings (updated daily) can be viewed at https://www.invesco.com/portal/site/us/investors/etfs/.
After DWA started providing the ETFs portfolios, they set up a model called the Power 4. Its goal was to own the top 4 of these ETFs based on performance and go to cash when the top 4 were not positive. I tried to follow this model with limited success – if I had signed up for their web site service I probably would have been more successful. However, two weeks ago Invesco came out with another ETF which does it for me. PowerShares DWA Tactical Sector Rotation Portfolio (DWTR) is the ETF. Each month it is updated with the top 4 ETFs. Current it holds PSL – Consumer Staples, PEZ – Consumer Cyclicals, PTH – Healthcare, and PTF – Technology.
DWTR is expensive for an ETF – management fee of 0.75% per year (which includes the fees for ETFs it holds). However Fidelity Select Retailing Portfolio management fee is 0.81%, with a voluntary cap of 1.15% – a relative low fee for a mutual fund. Fidelity does charge me $8 to buy or sell DWTR, but there is no minimum holding period, orders can be executed anytime the market is open (mutual funds can only be purchased or sold at market close), and stop loss or stop limit order can be used.
Another interesting thing about ETFs, unlike mutual funds, you do not have to pay taxes for capital gains and losses caused by the ETF. Unlike funds which give you a distribution of capital gains and losses, ETFs do not. I’m not sure how it works, but you only pay capital gains and losses as a result of you selling the ETF.
All in all I think this does a better job in momentum investing than I have been doing since 1/6/82. I have switched my Power 4 portfolio to 100% DWTR and am maintaining a 7% stop loss. If it works out as well as I think it should, I may quit following Fidelity funds completely. I am also sure that there are other rotational ETFs, I’ve just not found them.
Returns for the month of September were nothing.
In September IRA#1 0%, IRA#2 0%, PDP PIE PIZ DWAS 0%, QQQ 0%, SPY/RSP 0%, Power4 0%.
For the last 3 months, IRA#1 -21%, IRS#2 -5%, PDPetc -3%, QQQ new -5%, SPY/RSP new -7%, Power4 -4%.
September portfolio changes:
IRA#1 – None
IRA#2 – None.
PDP PIE PIX DWAS – None
QQQ – None – third month for this portfolio.
SPY/RSP – None – third month for this portfolio.
Power4 – None
IBD TBP’s Market Pulse is “Confirmed Uptrend” as of 10/02/15 – a time to buy. It has been 22 days since IBD said we are in an uptrend. I am still conviced the market is headed for trouble, but I only invest based on the numbers. I am buying SSoftware&ComputerServices and MTK as the ETF equivalent.
My current investments:
IRA#1 and IRA#2
SRetailing has a price of 103.61, a sell price 101.29, a rank of 01, and is a Hold.
IRA#2
SITServices has a price of 41.77, a sell price 39.68, a rank of 02, and is a Hold.
My portfolio changes this weekend:
IRA #1 – None
IRA #2 – Buy 20% SSoftware&ComputerServices
My portfolio market exposure after this weekend’s changes:
IRA #1 – 100% invested
IRA #2 – 60% invested